
25. Son Volt -
A Retrospective; best song: "Windfall" (of course)

24. The Magic Numbers -
The Magic Numbers; best song: "Mornings Eleven"

23. Bonnie Prince Billy/Matt Sweeney -
Superwolf; best song: "My Home is the Sea"

22. Son Volt -
Okemah and the Melody of Riot; best song:"6 String Belief"

21. John Vanderslice -
Pixel Revolt; best song: "Exodus Damage"

20. Stephen Malkmus -
Face the Truth; best song: "Freeze the Saints"

19. Sun Kil Moon -
Tiny Cities; best song: "Never Ending Math Equation"

18. The Decemberists -
Picaresque; best song: "On a Bus Mall"

17. Bloc Party -
Silent Alarm; best song: "Like Eating Glass"

16. Andrew Bird -
The Mysterious Production of Eggs; best song: "Fake Palindrones"

15. Clem Snide -
End of Love; best song: "End of Love"

14. Death Cab For Cutie -
Plans; best song: "Your Heart is an Empty Room"

13. Stars -
Set Yourself on Fire; best song: "Set Yourself On Fire"

12. Kings of Leon -
Aha Shake Heartbreak; best song: "The Bucket"

11. Sigur Ros' -
Takk'; best song: "Milano'"

10. The Go! Team -
Thunder, Lightning, Strike (Remastered for US) best songs (tie): "Everybody's a VIP" and "Ladyflash"

9. Bright Eyes -
Digital Ash in a Digital Urn; best song: "Hit the Switch"

8. Wolf Parade -
Apologies to the Queen Mary; best song: "Shine a Light"

7. Broken Social Scene -
Broken Social Scene; best song: "7/4 Shoreline"

6. The New Pornographers -
Twin Cinema; best song: "The Bleeding Heart Show"

5. Spoon -
Gimme Fiction; best song: "The Beast and Dragon, Adored"

4. Bright Eyes -
I'm Wide Awake Its Morning; best song: "Road to Joy"

3. My Morning Jacket -
Z; best song: "Wordless Chorus"

2. Sufjan Stevens -
Come and Feel the Illinoise; best song: "Chicago"

1. Clap Your Hands Say Yeah! -
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah!;
best songs: (tie) "In this Home on Ice" and "Skin of My Yellow Country Teeth"